JOIN GARDEN IN 5 LIVE, A 1-DAY VIRTUAL EVENT WITH NICOLE & FRIENDS → REGISTER FOR FREE HERE

Kitchen Garden to Table
Published May 2, 2022 by Nicole Burke

How to Make Garden-Fresh Pico de Gallo

Filed Under:
recipes
tomatoes
peppers
cilantro
garden to table
Garden-Fresh Pico de Gallo recipe

Pico de Gallo Is an Easy, Healthy Recipe That Doesn't Involve Cooking

I'd much rather be tending my garden than standing over a hot stove stirring something. That's why my ideal recipes are those that you can assemble, not cook. When they call for lots of garden-fresh ingredients like this easy pico de gallo recipe, you're really just tossing a bunch of healthy things into a bowl!

Another great thing about this recipe is that you can customize it based on your tastes and the ingredients you have available.

How to Make Garden-Fresh Pico de Gallo

Pico de Gallo vs Salsa

Even though pico de gallo and red salsa share the same basic ingredients, their preparation methods can differ.

The salsa my family ate by the bowlful at TexMex restaurants while we were living in Houston tended to be on the runnier side. Pico de gallo is made with diced ingredients that have not been blended or pureed, so the only liquid in pico comes from the lime and the natural juiciness of the tomatoes.

While some salsas might be cooked on the stove or call for tomatoes that have been roasted or stewed, pico de gallo is traditionally made from only fresh, raw ingredients.

If you're looking for something to add more texture to your tacos, pico de gallo is your answer.

How to Make Garden-Fresh Pico de Gallo - tomatoes on vine

Garden-Fresh Pico de Gallo Ingredients

When you're serving something raw, it's important to use the freshest ingredients possible. Let's see which ingredients you might be able to pull from your garden and toss into some delicious pico.

Tomatoes

Many pico de gallo recipes call for roma (or plum) tomatoes, which are less watery than other varieties. I like to use cherry tomatoes because that's what I'm most likely to have growing up my arch trellises. Plus, you can't beat their flavor. Choose your ripest, plumpest tomatoes for this recipe.

(Want to give growing your own cherry tomatoes a try? Check out our complete guide here.)

How to Make Garden-Fresh Pico de Gallo - cherry tomatoes

Garlic and Onions

You can use red or white onions, whatever you've got stored or can find fresh at the farmers' market.

Cilantro

When my cilantro, parsley, and dill are in season, I look for recipes where I can use a lot of leaves. Cilantro is ideal to add that zestier flavor to pico de gallo, but if you think it tastes like soap, you can use parsley instead to still get some nice green color.

(Check out my tips on how to grow your own cilantro here. You'll have enough leaves to make pico for days.)

cilantro

Peppers

Most of the pico de gallo recipes you'll find call for fresh jalapeño. If you'd like to dial down the heat a bit, try a serrano pepper, bell pepper, or one of my favorites, shishito pepper. If you'd prefer foregoing the heat entirely, you can swap the pepper for black beans or corn.

pico de gallo ingredient - garden-fresh peppers

Pico de Gallo Ingredient List

In addition to the fresh ingredients, we'll add some lime juice and seasoning.

  • 1 1/2 pounds red tomatoes
  • 1 white or red onion
  • 1/2 cup fresh cilantro (about one bunch)
  • 1 medium-sized pepper (jalapeño, serrano, or shishito)
  • 1/4 cup lime juice
  • 1 clove of garlic
  • 1 pinch of ground cumin
  • salt and ground black pepper to taste
How to Make Garden-Fresh Pico de Gallo - ingredients
Want to learn tips and tricks to grow your own fresh ingredients in a thriving kitchen garden?

Join Gardenary 365

Gardenary 365 is our new membership subscription program. You'll get access to our complete course library, including Kitchen Garden Academy, Herb Garden Guide, Salad School, and so much more. Even if you just want to learn how to grow your own herbs, you'll find so much helpful material inside 365.

Step-by-Step Directions

Step One

Chop your onion finely.

Remove the seeds from your pepper if you'd prefer less heat. Remove the ribs and chop the flesh finely.

Transfer chopped onion and pepper to a large bowl, add a pinch of salt, and set aside to marinate.

Step Two

Core your tomatoes and chop the red flesh finely. Chop the cilantro finely. (Don't be afraid to chop the stems of cilantro—they're packed with flavor too.)

Mince your garlic clove.

Step Three

Add the tomatoes, garlic, and parsley to the marinated bowl of onions and peppers.

How to Make Garden-Fresh Pico de Gallo - ingredients in bowl

Add the lime juice, cumin, salt, and pepper.

squeezing lime juice onto pico de gallo

Stir your ingredients together.

stirring pico de gallo with hands

Step Four

Let your pico de gallo rest for a bit before serving to allow all the flavors to mingle. Place in the fridge for at least 15 minutes (you'll get the best flavor if you can leave it for 2 to 3 hours).

Step Five

Serve your pico with a slotted spoon to prevent all the tomato juice that will accumulate from making your chips or tortillas soggy.

Pico de gallo can be eaten with tortilla chips, added as a taco topper, stuffed into quesadillas, or mixed with scrambled eggs.

pico de gallo

How Long Does Pico de Gallo Last?

This is a dish best served fresh as tomatoes tend to lose their flavor if refrigerated. If you do have leftovers, you can store them in the fridge inside an airtight container for up to 3 days.

Enjoy!

Want to learn tips and tricks to grow your own fresh ingredients in a thriving kitchen garden?

Join Gardenary 365

Gardenary 365 is our new membership subscription program. You'll get access to our complete course library, including Kitchen Garden Academy, Herb Garden Guide, Salad School, and so much more. Even if you just want to learn how to grow your own herbs, you'll find so much helpful material inside 365.

How to Make Garden-Fresh Pico de Gallo